Home / Answers

In the Charleston, should I pass for my own hand or pass defensively?

Your own hand comes first, and then you do the best you can with whatever is left over. The trap is trying to pass for two hands at once, which leaves you close to neither. Whatever else you do, two passes are worth avoiding on principle: never pass like numbers, and never pass three of a kind.

Answered by Prim. Last reviewed 2026-08-21.

Your hand first, defense out of the leftovers

There is a version of defensive passing that costs you the game. It happens when a player is so worried about helping somebody that they start keeping tiles they do not want and passing tiles they do, and arrives at the first discard with a rack that is not going anywhere. Defense in the Charleston is what you do with the tiles you were going to pass anyway, not a reason to pass different ones.

The specific failure to watch for is trying to pass for two hands at once. Say you are holding a pair of 5 Dots that points toward Like Numbers, and a 4, 5, 6 in Craks that points toward a Consecutive Run. Keep both and you have nothing spare to give away, so you start passing tiles that the hand you eventually choose actually needed. By the third pass you are close to neither, holding the beginnings of two hands. The player who picked one of them at the first pass has spent all three passes clearing space for it, and arrives at the wall genuinely close to something.

The passes that hand somebody a hand

Never pass like numbers. Three tiles of the same number across different suits is close to a gift, because so much of the card is built on exactly that shape. It is at least as dangerous as passing a pair, and most players do it without noticing because the tiles do not look connected in their own rack.

Never pass three of a kind. This one is obvious once said and still happens, usually because a player has decided they are not playing that suit and clears it out in one motion.

Two winds together is nearly as bad. Winds are concentrated: there are only four of them, several sections of the card lean on them heavily, and handing over two at once narrows somebody's search enormously.

The ideal throwaway pass

Sooner or later you have three tiles to give and no idea which are safe. The pass you want is a mixture: a wind, a high number in one suit, a low number in a different suit, one odd and one even. Scattered like that, it tells the receiver nothing about what you are doing and helps them with nothing they are doing.

It is worth building the habit, because the alternative is what most people do, which is pass three tiles of one suit because it is tidy. Tidy passes are readable passes.

A test you can run on yourself

Play one game passing with no defensive thought at all, purely for your own rack. Play a second with a little defensive care. Play a third with heightened defense, where you are genuinely weighing every tile you give away. Then compare how the three went.

Almost nobody does this, and it is the only way to find your own setting rather than inheriting somebody else's. The answer is not the same for every player, and it is not the same at every table.